How Social Mobility and Race Impacts Graduate Access to Professional Careers

As corporations and businesses mark Black History Month and a wider national conversation around race equity and DEI initiatives continues, important research is being conducted on the correlations between access to professional careers for low socio-economic background and black heritage individuals. 

In March 2025, UCL researchers at the Centre for Education Policy & Equalising Opportunities specifically investigated the connection between working class backgrounds and ethnic minority heritage in relation to access to professional careers. The research, ‘Inequalities in Access to Professional Occupations’, has found that:

  • Disadvantaged groups are applying to professional roles but are not being offered positions at the same rate as their more advantaged peers
  • During the application process, black applicants are 37% less likely to pass online screening test stage than their white peers 
  • At the final stage of the application process, black applicants were 33% less likely to receive a job offer than ‘like for like’ white candidates.
  • There appears to be a double disadvantage for individuals of working class and ethnic minority heritage

UCL's latest findings support BTC research published in 2024 with Bain & Company. Why We Need to Fix the Broken Pipeline revealed that black graduates are twice as likely to be rejected for jobs at top businesses despite comprising 8% of the UK university population and 4% at the top 20 universities. Our research exposes the persistence of inequity in sectors that may think they have solved the recruitment challenge. The promise of meritocracy in Britain’s top professions is starkly challenged when evidence is combined. When set alongside a recent study from UCL, the picture becomes more complex: even when class background is accounted for, black applicants remain significantly less likely to receive job offers than their white counterparts. Together, these studies dismantle the narrative that the underrepresentation of black professionals is a ‘pipeline problem’ and instead point to systemic racial bias embedded within recruitment and selection processes themselves. The second phase of UCL's important work is beginning this month.

 

Social Mobility and the Timing Trap: Why Early Applications Matter

In the race for professional careers, timing of applications is proving to be a hidden barrier to social mobility. The research found that after controlling for variables such as qualifications, university attended, subject studied and personal characteristics, working-class applicants were less likely to receive offers because they tend to apply later. The date of application accounts for 11% of the offer gap in sectors including accounting and professional services. Applying just one month earlier increased a candidate’s chances by 6%; a significant boost in a competitive market.

Data from the Institute of Student Employers shows that nearly 40% of graduate schemes closed between October and December in the 2023–24 cycle. By early October, some firms had already received 30% of applications and made half of their job offers for roles starting the following September. With application volumes surging, partly due to AI-assisted submissions and the removal of academic filters, employers are closing campaigns earlier, inadvertently disadvantageing those who apply later

.

The problem extends beyond graduate schemes. Internships, often a gateway to full-time roles, show similar patterns. Students from state schools are underrepresented in internship applications, while those from private schools are overrepresented. Yet when state school students do apply, they perform just as well. The challenge lies not in capability but in readiness - knowing when and how to apply.

According to the research, this readiness gap is shaped by multiple factors: lack of awareness about deadlines, lower confidence, and competing priorities such as part-time work. The result is a treadmill of work experience opportunities that starts earlier and moves faster than many disadvantaged students can keep up with. As one student put it, “having the right information makes it easier to be lucky.”

To level the playing field, the report recommends a coordinated effort between employers and universities. Employers should clearly communicate recruitment timelines and consider extending eligibility for internships and spring weeks. Universities must embed career awareness into the curriculum early and support students from underrepresented backgrounds with tailored guidance and confidence-building resources.

Ultimately, improving application readiness is a practical and impactful way to boost social mobility. It’s not just about who applies but when they apply; in today’s competitive landscape the early bird doesn’t just catch the worm: it catches the job.

Further Reading

https://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/2025/mar/uk-employers-less-likely-recruit-disadvantaged-ethnic-minority-graduates 

https://blogs.ucl.ac.uk/cepeo/2025/03/10/the-early-bird-catches-the-worm-why-applying-early-matters-for-social-mobility/ 

https://econpapers.repec.org/paper/uclcepeow/25-01.htm

Written by

Black Talent Charter
July 2, 2025

From Aspiration to Influence: 5 Key Lessons on the Journey to the C-suite

On 26 June, the BTC ran our first C-suite readiness conference for emerging senior leaders. The day brought together a diverse group of executives with a shared desire, not just to rise to the top, but to understand what it takes to thrive
June 24, 2025

Spotlight Interview - Raveena Dhadwal, Inclusion, Diversity and Equity Manager, KPMG

Raveena Dhadwal, Inclusion Diversity and Equity Manager at KPMG discusses her approach and challenges when it comes to her job as well as what initiatives KPMG are undertaking to promote a truly inclusive workplace.
June 10, 2025

Standard Chartered joins the BTC

We are thrilled to welcome Standard Chartered Bank as the newest Signatory of the Black Talent Charter. The bank joins over twenty Signatories working in collaboration to accelerate meaningful progress on race equity in business